i wanna make bagels

topic posted Sun, June 22, 2008 - 7:38 AM by  subbygirl
Anyone here make their own? i wonder how hard it is to do. the thought of fresh, warm, homemade bagels on a Sunday morning sounds delish! any recipes or techniques out there that you've tried and use? TIA
posted by:
subbygirl
SF Bay Area
  • Re: i wanna make bagels

    Sun, June 22, 2008 - 7:53 AM
    Making bagels is a bit of an involved process.. more so than the ingredients even. Once you have formed the bagels you then have to put them in boiling water to form the crust. take them out and then let them rise till time to bake them. I have a couple recipes that I will drop here when I get back to the computer. cool??
    • Re: i wanna make bagels

      Sun, June 22, 2008 - 8:43 AM
      thanks! yeha, i know they are time consuming, but still wanna give it a whirl =]
      • Re: i wanna make bagels

        Sun, June 22, 2008 - 9:28 AM
        they are worth it - but just like homemade yeast doughnuts, you'd have to get up at 3am to have them warm and fresh in the 'morning'. They sure are good for lunch though! And I'm more in the mood to enjoy, when I've had enough sleep on weekends. ;-)
        Good luck!
        Some recipes call for boiling them in salt water, and some use lye (like for pickles) I don't know how the results would differ.
        • Re: i wanna make bagels

          Sun, June 22, 2008 - 11:16 AM
          LOL yeah, i know (dreaming) but maybe fresh bagels with cream cheese and lox for dinner might work!
          • Re: i wanna make bagels

            Sun, June 22, 2008 - 11:32 AM
            I make them often (sourdough). I love the process, and they're fabulous. I always have a freezerful. Let me know if I can answer any questions or give you my recipe.
            • Re: i wanna make bagels

              Sun, June 22, 2008 - 12:47 PM
              i would love your recipe as i also have some sourdough starter that i'd like to use in them if possible. thanks!
              • Re: i wanna make bagels

                Mon, June 23, 2008 - 12:20 AM
                I'll be happy to give you my recipe and some starter. PM me so we can work out the details.
                • Re: i wanna make bagels

                  Sun, July 27, 2008 - 6:01 AM
                  Bagels 101

                  This is my version of Jo Goldenberg’s recipe found in Bernard Clayton’s, New Complete Book of Breads and though only minor changes were made, they seem to make all the difference to me.

                  *
                  Ingredients
                  3 to 4 cups of flour (I use half all-purpose and half bread flour as the bread flour in America has to much gluten for a light texture
                  Almost a full tablespoon of yeast
                  2 ½ Tablespoons sugar (this is actually less sugar than the original recipe)
                  1 Tablespoon salt (I use half Kosher and half table salt)
                  1 ½ cups warm water
                  *
                  In addition you will need a large pot (about 3 quarts) filled with water to which you add
                  ¼ teaspoon salt
                  1 Tablespoon sugar (either regular or malt if you have it)
                  Bring this to simmer when you turn the oven on to pre-heat
                  *
                  1 egg white mixed in a small bowl with about a Tablespoon of cold water
                  *
                  A baking sheet sprinkled liberally with cornmeal (or combination of meals like matzo, cornmeal and grits)

                  *

                  Mix warm water, yeast, sugar, salt and about 2 ½ cups of the flour and beat a couple of minutes.
                  Let rest a couple of minute and add enough flour to make manageable this should look like a shaggy mass of dough.
                  Turn out onto a bread board of other lightly floured surface and knead a few minute or until it becomes smooth and not sticky.
                  Cover and wait about five minutes then continue to knead until the dough is soft and springy.

                  Cover and let set in a warm place for about an hour or till doubled.
                  Cut into 6 pieces and with lightly floured hands work each piece into a small ball.
                  Let rest a couple of minutes then poke a hole into the center of each ball, these don’t have to look perfect, just get them into a bagel like shape.
                  Cover with damp towel.
                  Preheat oven to 400 and put the water pot on to simmer.
                  When oven is heated and water is simmering (not a boil) put a couple of bagels gently into the water about a half minute on each side (I use slotted spoons to turn and lift them out of water) do not crowd as they will swell slightly.
                  Then transfer to baking sheet and brush with egg wash. At this point put on your favorite topping(s) and bake about 25- 30 minutes till golden brown.

                  Place on racks to cool.
                  (You can add the egg yolk to the dough during the initial mixing for egg bagels.)
                  Makes a half dozen large bagels.

                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: i wanna make bagels

                    Sun, July 27, 2008 - 6:03 AM
                    Oh yeah, bagels go stale fast due to their simmering in water. Freeze what's left and take them out to thaw when desired. If you leave them on the counter to thaw, wait until the moisture in the freezer bag is absorbed then toast, they are excellent.

Recent topics in "Baking (Breads and Pastry)"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
What went wrong with this pie? Leigh 16 August 14, 2008
Recomendations. christine 0 July 31, 2008
presentation or taste? 1 July 30, 2008
Amish Friendship Bread offlineTreja 4 June 27, 2008
ISO a Chewy Lemon Cookie Recipe MacMorrighan 4 June 22, 2008